Book Club Questions for Cedar Hollow Promises
Cedar Hollow Promises was written to be discussed. These questions are designed to open conversation, not close it — to help your group move beneath the surface of the story and into the deeper water.
The following questions are drawn from the novel's own "Ask The Witness: Deep Edition" section, expanded with discussion prompts for groups who want to go deeper. Cedar Hollow Promises was designed for exactly this kind of conversation.
On Love and Consequence
1. Lena accepts Malik's friend request after three weeks of hesitation. What do you think those three weeks felt like — and what ultimately made her say yes? 2. Lena tells herself repeatedly that she and Malik are "just old classmates" and that their connection is temporary. At what point does she stop believing her own narrative? 3. The novel asks: Are promises made in confinement stronger… or more fragile when freedom comes? What do you think?
On Transformation and Justice
4. Is Malik defined by his worst decision — or by who he became after it? Can the answer be both at once? 5. The System Impact Appendix identifies three gaps in the correctional system: accountability, transformation, and reintegration. Which gap do you think is most costly — to individuals, to society, to victims' families? 6. Malik transforms internally without systemic support. What does that say about the relationship between personal change and institutional design?
On Faith and Desire
7. When Lena reads Proverbs 7:25-27, she says: "Either she believed it, or she didn't. And if she did, something in her life had to change." What do you think she ultimately chose — and what did it cost her? 8. Faith functions as both comfort and conviction in this novel. How do you read the tension between Lena's love for Malik and her faith commitments?
On the Alternate Timelines
9. Which of the three alternate timelines felt most honest to you, and why? 10. The novel argues that Malik and Lena's connection gains its depth specifically from suffering. Do you agree? Can love built on pain be as whole as love built on peace?
For the Room
11. Lena asks in Chapter 21: "Ten years, Malik, and we're still here. Is it enough?" How would you answer that question on her behalf? 12. The Witness asks throughout the novel: Who did Lena forgive, and did she finally choose herself? Does the story answer that? Do you?
Join the Reader List
Get new journal entries, behind-the-story features, and updates from Cedar Hollow Promises delivered to your inbox.